Featured post

Textbook: Writing for Statistics and Data Science

If you are looking for my textbook Writing for Statistics and Data Science here it is for free in the Open Educational Resource Commons. Wri...

Showing posts with label reviews. Show all posts
Showing posts with label reviews. Show all posts

Saturday, 9 November 2019

Basketball Data Science with Applications in R - An Advance Review

My overall impression of "Basketball Data Science" is that it's exactly the sort of book I would recommend to an instructor or able student of statistics in sport. Most of my criticisms are because it's not the book I imagine I would have written, not because the book isn't good.

Friday, 8 November 2019

Postmortems from 'Game Developer', a book review


"Postmortems from 'Game Developer'", edited by Austin Grossman is a collection of after-the-fact analyses of popular video games that had been recently developed and sold. The analyses are all written by senior members of each game's development team, and usually the game's head creator. "Postmortems" was published in 2003, so the games being analyzed include Diablo 2, Age of Empires, System Shock 2, and Black and White.

I purchased my copy from a thrift store in 2016, which had a suggested Canadian price of $42. This copy had several discount stickers on it, one of which had the book for sale for $0.84, a 98% discount.

Wednesday, 14 August 2019

Replication report: Multilevel-Linear-Models using SAS and SPSS for repeated measures designs


The following is a report on the reproduction of the statistical work in the paper “Differences of Type I error rates for ANOVA and Multilevel-Linear-Models using SAS and SPSS for repeated measures designs" by Nicolas Haverkamp and AndrĂ© Beauducel at the University of Bonn.

Thursday, 20 June 2019

Replication Report - Informative Priors and Bayesian Updating


The following is a report on the reproduction of the statistical work in the paper "The use of informative priors and Bayesian updating: implications for behavioral research" by Charlotte O. Brand et al.

The original paper was accepted for publication by Meta-Psychology, https://open.lnu.se/index.php/metapsychology, a journal focused on methodology and reproductions of existing work. This report continues my attempt to establishing a standard for replication reports according to the Psych Data Standards found here https://github.com/psych-ds/psych-DS


Friday, 8 February 2019

Replication Report - Signal Detection Analysis

The following is a report on the reproduction of the statistical work in the paper “Insights into Criteria for Statistical Significance from Signal Detection Analysis” by Jessica K. Witt at Colorado State University.

The original paper was accepted for publication by the Journal of Meta-Psychology, a journal focused on methodology and reproductions of existing work. This report on is my first attempt at establishing a standard template for future such reports according to the Psych Data Standards found here https://github.com/psych-ds/psych-DS

Saturday, 26 January 2019

I read this: Smart Baseball

Smart Baseball, by Keith Law, exposes many common baseball statistics like batting average for the garbage they are. He does this in an approachable, narrative style that will appeal to long-time baseball fans. It's very light on statistics, but Law obviously knows his stuff; he just isn't interested in showing off the details.

Monday, 12 November 2018

Four OJS manuscript reviews, 2015-2018

Here is a dump of the remaining reviews I made for Scirp's Open Journal of Statistics from 2015 to 2018. For reasons explained in The Last Review I'll Ever Do For OJS, I won't provide additional linking information. These reviews are here as how-to examples.


Monday, 22 October 2018

The Last Review I'll Do For the Open Journal of Statistics

The following review is for a paper that is currently published in the Scientific Research Publishing's Open Journal of Statistics (link omitted intentionally). I accepted the responsibility to review it, found it unfit for publication, and returned a review less than a month later only to find that the paper had already been published as is.

I won't be reviewing for this journal or this publishing house again. To ask for my review, get my assent, and not wait a reasonable time (a month, really?), for the review before going ahead and publishing is disrespectful of my time. It also smacks of predatory journal behaviour. 
Was there another peer reviewer and were they qualified to perform the review? Read my review, and the paper, and judge for yourself.

Friday, 28 September 2018

Open Reviews 3 - Open Journal of Statistics 2015

 This was the third paper I reviewed for the predatory publisher Scientific Research Publishing's Open Journal of Statistics.

The manuscript was a simulation study of a new computational method. It was the first paper I had reviewed in three years, as I had been otherwise swamped in coursework. You can see that I still wasn't clear on the differences of the roles of copy-editor and reviewer by the extensive writing feedback I gave. By word count, the review was a third as long as the manuscript itself.


Friday, 21 September 2018

Open Reviews 2 - Open Journal of Statistics 2012

These were the first two papers I reviewed for  Scientific Research Publishing's Open Journal of Statistics, back in 2012. The first one is 'An Exceptional Generalization of the Poisson Distribution', and the second one was 'A Proposed Statistical Method to Explore Quality of Quantitative Data'.


Tuesday, 18 September 2018

Open Reviews 1 - Two Meta-Psychology Papers

This is the first post of several in which I publish the peer reviews I have previously given to journals. 

There are a few reasons for doing this, but the main one is purely mercenary: I want to get more return for the effort I put into carefully reading and critiquing these articles.